Disclosure: Some of the links below are affiliate links. At no cost to you, I will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase.
Animal costumes are always a fun choice for a Halloween costume! If you’re not sure what animal you’d like to dress up as, you’re sure to find one you love on this list of modest animal costumes.
Modest Animal Costume #1 – Deer
This modest deer costume from The Sugared Lemon is just so cute! She’s wearing deer ears and antlers, a tan cable-knit turtleneck sweater, a cream tulle skirt, and tan heels. She also did really cute deer makeup. This is my favorite of these modest animal costumes.
Shop this look:
- Similar deer costume here
- Similar antlers headband here
- Similar sweater here
- Similar skirt here
- Similar heels here
- Makeup kit here
Related Content: 17 Modest Superhero Costumes For Women
2. Fox
Rach Martino dressed up as a fox. This is a really fun modest animal costume! She’s wearing a fox ears headband, a rust orange cable knit sweater, and an orange skirt. She also did fox makeup on her face. I love the little nose she put on with the makeup!
Shop this look:
3. Unicorn
Unicorns are so fun and trendy. This unicorn costume is made up of a unicorn horn, purple hair, a mint v-neck shirt, a blush pink tulle skirt, and purple flat shoes. I love all the pastel colors of this costume.
Shop this look:
- Similar unicorn costume here
- Unicorn headband here
- Purple wig here
- Similar v-neck here
- Similar skirt here
- Similar shoes here
Related Content: 19 Modest Food Costumes For Women
4. Owl
Wonderland Sam is wearing a DIY owl costume. She has on an owl eye mask, an owl dress, wings, black leggings, and black combat boots.
Shop this look:
5. Cat
This modest cat costume is fun for women of all ages and even teens. This costume is a black cat ears headband, a black long sleeve shirt, a black tulle skirt, black leggings, and black cat makeup. You could also add a tail and a collar to the costume.
Shop this look:
- Similar cat ears here
- Similar shirt here
- Similar skirt here
- Similar black leggings here
- Black makeup here
- Cat tail, collar, and ears here
6. Smokey Bear
The Merry Thought made this DIY Smokey Bear costume for Halloween. She’s wearing a brown hat that she used sticker letters to make it say “Smokey”, a brown faux fur vest, a brown long sleeve shirt, a brown belt, and jeans. She’s holding a shovel and did bear makeup on her face. This is one of the most unique modest animal costumes.
Shop this look:
- Similar hat here
- Letter stickers here
- Similar vest here
- Similar shirt here
- Similar belt here
- Similar jeans here
- Similar shovel here
- Black makeup here
7. Spider
I love this take on a spider costume from Pretty Life Girls. Spiders are perfect for Halloween! She’s wearing a spider headband, spiderweb face tattoos, a black shirt with a white spiderweb on it, black leggings, and black ankle boots.
Shop this look:
- Similar spider headband here
- Similar spider web face tattoos here
- Similar shirt here
- Similar leggings here
- Similar ankle boots here
8. Leopard
This leopard costume from The Ashley Edit is so fierce! She’s wearing a leopard ears headband, a leopard print button down shirt, a cream sherpa jacket, a leather skirt, leopard print leggings, and brown boots. She did leopard makeup on her face and put some leopard print tattoos to make it extra fun. Halloween costumes like this are so fun!
Shop this look:
- Similar leopard ears here
- Similar leopard shirt here
- Similar sherpa jacket here
- Similar skirt here
- Similar leopard leggings here
- Similar boots here
- Leopard print tattoos here
- Leopard makeup kit here
9. Flamingo
This DIY Halloween costume is a flamingo from Pretty Providence is easy to put together at the last minute. It has a beak, a headband with pink feathers, a pink short sleeve shirt with pink feathers glued on, and pink and white tie dye leggings. If you’re not up for making a costume, but still want to be a flamingo, you could get a flamingo onesie instead.
Shop this look:
- Pink feathers here
- Mask with beak here
- Similar shirt here
- Similar leggings here
- Flamingo onesie here
10. Lion
This cute lion costume is from The Sewcial. She’s wearing a lion ears headband, a lion tail, a black long sleeve shirt, a brown tutu skirt, and black leggings. She also did some lion makeup on her face.
Shop this look:
- Similar lion ears headband and tail here
- Similar shirt here
- Similar skirt here
- Similar leggings here
- Lion makeup kit here
11. Giraffe
This DIY giraffe outfit is a one piece costume that is a giraffe print jumpsuit, brown shoe covers, and a giraffe ears headband. Giraffes are fun animals, but aren’t usually the first to come to mind, so this is a unique modest animal costume for Halloween.
Shop this look:
I hope you love the Halloween costume ideas in this post and found some inspiration for what you’re going to dress up as.
Pin this image to save these cute Halloween costumes for later!
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.