• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Cleo Madison
  • Style
    • Women’s Fashion
    • Disney Outfits
    • Modest Fashion
    • Accessories
  • Lifestyle
    • Holiday
  • Beauty
  • Policies
    • Privacy
    • Accessibility
    • Terms & Conditions

83 Easy Modest Halloween Costumes You’ll Love

Published by Liz Morgan

Disclosure: Some of the links below are affiliate links. At no cost to you, we will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase.

Halloween is coming soon, so it’s time to start thinking about costume ideas. Halloween seems to be an excuse for women to show a lot of skin.

For women who dress modestly, it can be a challenge to find or make a modest Halloween costume. We’ve searched everywhere to find these super cute and modest Halloween costumes for women!

Modest Halloween Costume #1 – Elsa

Modest elsa halloween costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar Elsa costume here
  • Similar dress here
  • Similar lace top here
  • Elsa wig here

Merrick’s Art has some of the trendiest costumes out there.

You’re sure to love the way she styled these Disney Princess costumes.

This Elsa costume is made from a light blue dress and a white, lace, long sleeve top with a white layering tee underneath.

2. Inside Out Anxiety Costume

anxiety costume

Shop this costume:

  • Anxiety costume here
  • Jeans here

Anxiety is a really cute and popular costume this year! She is a character from Inside Out 2 that many people feel they can relate to.

For this costume I bought an Anxiety costume that came with the striped shirt, a headband hairpiece, and her glasses.

I’m wearing a size small in the costume and it fits perfectly. I love that it’s warm because it’s always cold where I live on Halloween.

I paired my costume with some high waisted mom jeans and white sneakers.

3. Belle

Modest belle halloween costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar Belle costume here
  • Similar apron here
  • Similar shoes here
  • Similar bow here

For a modest Belle costume, you need a blue midi dress, a white apron, a bow in your hair, and black heels.

Related Content: 10 Maternity Halloween Costumes That Show Off Your Bump

4. Ariel

modest little mermaid halloween costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar top here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Ariel wig here
  • Shell stencil here
  • Purple paint here
  • Similar purse here
  • Similar Ariel costume here

For a modest Ariel costume, you need a white t-shirt and teal maxi skirt. 

This shirt has shells stenciled on it with paint to look like a mermaid’s shell bra. She also has a small yellow purse.

5. Bat

DIY bat costume from She Knows blog

Shop this look:

  • Similar dress here
  • Similar bat ears here
  • Similar bat wings here
  • Similar lace up heels here

For this bat costume, you need a black knee length or midi dress, some black fabric, bat ears, and black shoes. 

You can get a black dress and use it for your costume, then continue to wear it after Halloween.

6. Mirabel Costume

mirabel encanto costume

Shop this costume:

  • Mirabel costume + purse here
  • Mirabel glasses here

My kids and I love the Encanto movie, so I was very excited to dress up as Mirabel, the main character from this Disney movie.

I’m wearing a costume of her dress that she wears in the movie and it came with her purse. I bought an accessory set that came with her round green glasses.

I’m wearing a size small in the costume and it’s true to size. This dress is really comfortable and affordable.

7. Dalmatian

Easy DIY dalmatian dog costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar dalmatian costume here
  • Similar sweater vest here
  • Similar black tee here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Similar leggings here
  • Similar booties here

This adorable Dalmatian costume is so easy to put together.

You need a black shirt, a white sweater vest, a black and white polka dot skirt, white booties, and black leggings.

The thing that really makes this costume come together as a dog is the make-up. Lauryncakes did really cute make-up and put her hair into pigtails.

Related Content: 19 Modest Fall Dresses You Should Definitely Buy

8. Inside Out Sadness Costume

sadness inside out costume

Shop this costume:

  • Sweater here
  • Blue wig here
  • Similar glasses here
  • Similar jeans here
  • Similar sneakers here

I love this modest Sadness costume from the Inside Out movies!

For this costume I’m wearing a blue wig, black round glasses, a light blue turtleneck sweater, blue mom jeans, and white sneakers.

9. Minnie Mouse Costume

minnie mouse costume for women

Shop this costume:

  • Minnie Mouse costume here
  • Yellow shoes here
  • Similar shirt here

For this cute Minnie Mouse costume I am wearing a black shirt, yellow flats, and a kit with Minnie Mouse costume pieces in it.

The Minnie Mouse costume came with the skirt, gloves, and Minnie ears.

10. Witch

Modest witch costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar witch costume here
  • Similar dress here
  • Similar hat here
  • Similar black booties here
  • Similar tights here

Dressing up as a witch is timeless. It will always be a fun costume.

Denise from Makin Lemonade used a black short sleeve dress for this costume.

She styled it with a black witch hat, black booties, and black tights. 

11. Eleven From Stranger Things

Dress up as Eleven from Stranger Things

Shop this look:

  • Long sleeve Eleven costume here
  • Short sleeve Eleven costume here
  • Similar dress here
  • Similar white shirt here
  • Similar bomber jacket here
  • Socks here
  • Shoes here

Stranger Things was easily one of the most talked about tv shows last fall, and for a good reason.

It was intriguing! Dressing up as Eleven, the girl, has become a popular costume for girls and women of all ages.

To do this costume, you need a light pink dress with short sleeves, a white collared shirt, striped high top socks, a black bomber jacket, and white tennis shoes.

To top it off, add a box of Eggo waffles.

Related Content: How To Style Booties (Even When You’re Scared You Won’t Pull Them Off)

12. Strawberry

DIY strawberry halloween costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar strawberry costume here
  • Similar dress here
  • Similar shoes here
  • Green foam sheets here
  • White felt sheets here
  • Headband here

This strawberry outfit is so cute and classy. It’s made with a red dress, that has white “seeds” added to it, a green stem for your hair, and black flats.

The white seeds are cutout from white felt and are glued or sewn onto the dress.

She made the green stem by hot gluing green foam sheets to a headband. This is a great DIY costume! 

13. Pineapple

Pineapple Halloween costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar pineapple shirt here
  • Similar yellow shirt here
  • Shoes here
  • Similar pineapple headband here

For the DIY pineapple costume, you’ll wear a yellow shirt that you put upside down V’s on.

You can make them out of tape or draw them on with a marker.

You’ll also need to make the green crown for the pineapple topper. This is green fun foam glued to a headband.

Related Content: 20 Family Halloween Costumes Perfect For Your Crew

14. Gumball Machine

DIY gumball machine costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar costume here
  • Similar gumball shirt here
  • Similar white t-shirt here
  • Similar red pants here
  • Shoes here
  • 1 inch pom pom balls here

Another super cute DIY costume is this gumball machine.

You’ll start by putting pom pom balls allover a white t-shirt. Also, make a 25 cent sign and wear red pants.

15. Snow White Costume

snow white costume

Shop this costume:

  • Snow White costume here

Snow White is such a classic Disney princess costume! It’s so recognizable and pretty.

This dress has short sleeves and is maxi length. I got it in size small and it fit me perfectly.

The costume also came with the cute red bow headband I’m wearing.

16. Anna From Frozen Costume

anna frozen 2 costume

Shop this costume:

  • Anna Frozen 2 costume here

If you’re in need of a warm Halloween costume, this is the perfect one to get!

This is an outfit that Anna wears in the movie Frozen 2. I got it in size small and it fit me really well.

It comes with the black and gold dress and the purple shawl/vest you wear over it. This costume is comfortable and not itchy like others.

17. Wednesday Addams

Modest Wednesday Addams costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar Wednesday Addams costume here
  • Similar dress here
  • Long sleeve dress option here
  • Wednesday Addams wig here
  • Similar tights here
  • Similar booties here
  • White collar here

Wednesday Addams is the queen of Halloween, so it’s one of the best costumes out there.

The key to pulling off Wednesday, is wearing lots and lots of black.

You need a black dress, black tights, and black shoes. You’ll also need a white collar and perfect pigtail braids. 

Related Content: 17 Modest Superhero Costumes For Women

18. Mary Poppins

Keiko Lynn's modest Mary Poppins outfit

Shop this look:

  • Similar Mary Poppins costume here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Similar white shirt here
  • Similar bow tie here
  • Similar umbrella here
  • Similar boots here
  • Similar gloves here
  • Similar purse here

If you’re looking for a classy costume, then Mary Poppins is one you should definitely consider.

You’ll need a white button down shirt, a long black skirt, a red bow tie, white gloves, black tights, black boots, and umbrella, and a big purse.

19. Bandit

Say Yes blog dressed up as a robber couples costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar shirt here
  • Similar mask here
  • Similar money bag here
  • Similar black gloves here
  • Similar black pants here

A bandit or robber is a pretty simple costume to put together.

The essential items for it are a black and white striped shirt, black pants, a black mask, black gloves, and a money bag.

Related Content: Modest Disney Halloween Costumes You’ll Love

20. Winifred Sanderson

winifred sanerson costume

Shop this costume:

  • Winifred Sanderson costume here
  • Winifred Sanderson wig here

Winifred is my favorite of the Sanderson sisters! I think this costume is so magical and chic.

I’m wearing a Winifred Sanderson costume of her dress in the movie. It is purple and green with gold on it, has long sleeves, and is floor length.

This is a great modest costume for wearing to work, school, Halloween parties, trick or treating, and more.

I already have red hair like Winifred, so I put my hair into little buns to look similar to hers, but you could add a wig to look really cool.

21. Mary Sanderson

mary sanderson costume

Shop this costume:

  • Mary Sanderson costume here

This Mary Sanderson costume is a dress that is just like what she wears in the movie Hocus Pocus.

I am wearing size small in it and it is true to size.

22. Sarah Sanderson

sarah sanderson costume

Shop this costume:

  • Sarah Sanderson costume here

This is a classic Sarah Sanderson costume that is really fun to wear.

I got it in size small and it is true to size.

23. Mummy

Do it yourself adult mummy costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar mummy costume here
  • White sheet here

This do it yourself mummy costume is very creative, but could also be pretty time consuming.

To make this, rip a white bed sheet into strips. Wrap those strips all around your whole body.

24. Down The Rabbit Hole

Modest down the rabbit hole from alice in wonderland costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar red blazer here
  • Similar white dress here
  • Similar bunny ears here
  • Similar bow tie here
  • Similar clock purse here

The Down the Rabbit Hole DIY costume by Color Me Courtney is so fun and modest.

This outfit requires a white knee length dress, a red blazer, a blue necktie, blue flats, bunny ears, and a clock purse to top it off.

25. Alice In Wonderland

Fashionable alice in wonderland halloween costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar Alice In Wonderland Costume here
  • Similar dress here
  • Similar apron here
  • Similar tights here
  • Similar bow here
  • Similar shoes here

The Alice in Wonderland costume consists of a light blue short sleeve dress, a white apron, white tights, black shoes, and a bow for your hair. Keiko Lynn even dressed up her little dog as the rabbit!

26. Hocus Pocus Witches

Sanderson Sisters dressed up for Halloween from Britco

Shop this look:

  • Similar Winifred Sanderson costume here
  • Similar Sarah Sanderson costume here
  • Similar Mary Sanderson costume here
  • Similar brooms here

Hocus Pocus is an iconic Halloween movie! My husband and I watch it every year on Halloween night. The witches in it are so creepy and also so cool.

Dressing up as the Sanderson Sisters, aka the Hocus Pocus witches, is a great costume for 3 girlfriends to do together.

There’s a lot that goes into these outfits. Dresses, corsets, boots, and brooms are the must-haves.

27. Pirate

modest pirate costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar pirate costume here
  • Similar bandana here
  • Similar boots here
  • Similar vest here

Sarah Forshaw put together an awesome modest pirate costume for Halloween! We love how modest she kept it.

This costume has black pants, a white ¾ length shirt, a black vest, a red bandana, lace up boots, and some jewelry.

28. Esmeralda

Esmerelda costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar Esmeralda costume here
  • Similar maxi skirt here
  • Similar headband here
  • Similar tambourine here

Esmeralda is a character from The Hunchback of Notre Dame.

She wears a purple maxi skirt, a white skirt, a purple sash with gold on it, a pink headband, and a tambourine.

29. Where’s Waldo

Where's Waldo costume for women

Shop this look:

  • Similar shirt, beanie, and glasses here
  • Similar shoes here

Where’s Waldo is a fun and easy costume to make! The most essential piece is the red and white top.

You could do a sweater or a shirt, depending on how cold it is on Halloween. You also need jeans, a red and white beanie, and glasses.

30. Mickey Mouse Costume

mickey mouse costume for women

Shop this costume:

  • Mickey Mouse costume here
  • Red shorts here
  • Yellow shoes here
  • Similar shirt here
  • Similar leggings here

Mickey Mouse is the most classic Disney character you can dress up as.

For this costume I got a Mickey Mouse costume kit that came with Mickey ears, gloves, and a yellow bowtie. I paired that with red high waisted shorts, a black shirt, black leggings, and yellow flats.

31. Peanut The Elephant Beanie Baby

halloween costume beanie baby elephant

Shop this look:

  • Similar elephant onesie here
  • Similar elephant ears here

Dressing up as a beanie baby isn’t as easy as a lot of the other costumes on this list. You have to find a store that has an elephant onesie, then make the TY tag yourself.

Print it out as big as you can, then use a ribbon to attach it to the onesie. You could also do this with other TY beanie babies!

32. Captain America

Captain America Halloween costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar dress here
  • Similar mask here
  • Similar long sleeve top here
  • Similar leggings here
  • Similar booties here

Ginger Parrish from The Parrish Place dressed up as a modest super hero a few years ago.

She wore a Captain America tank top dress with a black, long sleeve shirt and black leggings underneath.

She also wore black booties and a blue mask over her eyes. We love how she was able to take this tank top dress and make it into a modest costume.

33. Little Red Riding Hood

Dress up like the Little Red Riding Hood for Halloween

Shop this look:

  • Similar dress here
  • Similar cape here
  • Similar basket here
  • Similar tights here
  • Similar flats here

Abby from The Classy Giraffe dressed up as Little Red Riding Hood for her costume. She is wearing a navy and white gingham dress and a red, hooded cape.

She also has black tights, black flats, and a cute little basket.

We love how this costume is pretty simple, but it looks like you put a lot into it.

34. Deer

deer halloween costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar dress here
  • Similar vest here
  • Similar tights here
  • Similar booties here
  • Makeup kit here

Kate from Love Simple Kate dressed up as a deer and she looks darling! She is wearing a long sleeve brown dress, a fur vest, black tights, and brown booties.

She did her makeup to look like a deer and we can’t get enough of how cute it is.

35. Laffy Taffy

Modest Laffy Taffy Halloween costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar Laffy Taffy dress here
  • Similar tights here
  • Similar headband here
  • Similar tennis shoes here

Sam from The Pretty Life Girls dressed up in a Laffy Taffy costume. How fun is this?!

She is wearing a red Laffy Taffy costume dress, red tights, light red tennis shoes, and a red headband. 

36. Ice Cream Cone

Halloween ice cream costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar ice cream costume here
  • Similar top here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Similar heels here
  • Rainbow cardstock here
  • Red balloons here

Kelly from Studio DIY made this ice cream cone costume that is just adorable.

She is wearing a white top with scalloped edges, a tan knee-length pencil skirt, tan peep toe heels, and a cherry on her head.

She added rainbow sprinkles made from cardstock to her shirt.

She also made a cherry with a red balloon and some red paper. You can attach it to a headband, or you can pin it to your hair.

37. Cactus

Halloween cactus costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar sweater here
  • White yarn here
  • Similar flower here

Cacti are so cute and trendy right now. Lauren from LaurDIY is wearing a dark green sweater.

She tied white yarn into it to be the needles. She also has a flower headband on, like the cactus is blooming flowers.

38. Robin As Scoops Ahoy Worker from Stranger Things

Dress up as Robin from Stranger Things

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Scoops Ahoy costume here
  • Shoes here

Stranger Things is such a popular show and season 3 introduced the character Robin Buckley.

She works at the ice cream shop Scoops Ahoy and has to wear this uniform. 

39. Scarecrow

Dress up as a cute scarecrow for Halloween

Shop this look:

  • Similar overalls here
  • Similar top here
  • Similar hat here
  • Fake leaves here
  • Plaid patches here
  • Make-up kit here

Brit + Co dressed up as this super cute scarecrow.

She did her makeup like a scarecrow, then she’s wearing a straw hat, a red plaid flannel button down shirt, tan shoes, and overalls.

She put leaves on her hat and leaves and patches on her overalls. 

40. French Mime

Modest mime costume

Shop this look:

  • Similar hat here
  • Similar shoes here
  • Similar top here
  • Similar gloves here
  • Similar pants here
  • Similar suspenders here

Dress Cori Lynn dressed up as a French mime. This costume is so cool!

She is wearing a black and white striped long sleeve shirt, a white neck scarf, black pants, black suspenders, red flats, white gloves, and a black French hat.

41. Snapchat Butterfly Filter

Dress up as a Snapchat butterfly filter for Halloween

Shop this look:

  • Similar dress here
  • Similar booties here
  • Similar butterfly headband here

Emily from Modest Goddess dressed up as a butterfly Snapchat filter for Halloween.

She is wearing a yellow dress, brown heeled booties, and a butterfly headband. 

42. Sriracha

Dress up as a Sriracha bottle for Halloween

Shop this look:

  • Similar shirt here
  • Green construction paper here

Sarah Hearts wore this fun Sriracha sauce costume.

She is wearing a red shirt with the logo, then she made a lid out of green construction paper that she’s wearing on her head.

43. Where’s Waldo Costume For Women

wheres waldo costume for women

Shop Where’s Waldo costume here

Waldo is one of my favorite costumes I own! It’s cold on Halloween where we live, so I appreciate the long sleeve shirt and beanie. They keep me much warmer than other costumes I’ve worn!

This costume comes with a red and white striped shirt, a red and white beanie, and black round glasses. I wore it all with black mom jeans and white sneakers.

I got the costume in size x-small and it fit me perfectly.

Shop this Where’s Waldo costume here.

44. Velma From Scooby Doo

Dress up as Velma Dinkley from Scooby Doo for Halloween

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar Velma costume here
  • Similar sweater here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Similar heels here
  • Similar socks here
  • Similar glasses here
  • Velma wig here

This costume is Velma from Scooby Doo.

Marin is wearing a burnt orange turtle neck sweater, a brown pleated skirt, black glasses, red heels, and red socks. She is also carrying a book around.

45. Minnie Mouse

Minnie Mouse Halloween costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar Minnie Mouse costume here
  • Similar dress here
  • Similar ears here
  • Similar flats here
  • Similar tights here
  • Similar gloves here

Allison from Dream A Little Bigger is adorable dressed up as Minnie Mouse.

To be Minnie Mouse, she wore a red dress with white polka dots, Minnie Mouse ears that have a big red bow on them, a black long sleeve shirt, white gloves, black tights, and yellow flats.

46. Miss Universe

miss universe costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar dress here
  • Similar heels here
  • Similar sash here
  • Similar tiara here

Jackie from Living After Midnight dressed up as this funny Miss Universe costume.

She is dressed like a beauty queen, but also has the planets on her dress to represent the universe.

47. Flight Attendant

Dress up as a flight attendant for Halloween

Shop this look:

  • Similar flight attendant costume here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Similar shirt here
  • Similar neck scarf here
  • Similar shoes here
  • Similar suitcase here

This modest flight attendant costume is so unique.

It’s a red pencil skirt, a white button-down shirt, black heels, a neck scarf, and a carry-on size suitcase.

Which one of these modest Halloween costumes is your favorite? If you have any suggestions you’d like to add, let me know and I’ll add it! 

48. Princess Peach

princess peach halloween costume

Shop Princess Peach costume here

If you’re a fan of Mario, then you need this Princess Peach Halloween costume for work!

The costume comes with 3 pieces. It has the short sleeve pink dress, a tulle skirt to wear under the dress for added volume, and a crown that’s attached to a headband.

I’m wearing size small and it fit me perfectly.

Get my Princess Peach Halloween costume here.

49. Winnie The Pooh

winnie the pooh costume for women

Shop my costume here:

  • Ears here
  • Dress here
  • Red shirt here
  • Similar red shirt here
  • Similar shoes here

Winnie the Pooh is a honey loving bear who is sweet and thoughtful.

I dressed up as him for a Disney maternity costume when I was about 14 weeks pregnant. This costume works great whether you’re pregnant or not though.

I’m wearing a yellow dress with a short sleeve red crop top over it, Winnie the Pooh ears, and white sneakers.

50. Mary Poppins

Mary Poppins costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar Mary Poppins costume here
  • Mary Poppins accessory kit here

Mary Poppins is a nanny who is nurturing, adventurous, and strict.

This costume is based on her nanny outfit she wears in the movie.

51. Sailor

Sailor costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar dress here
  • Similar hat here
  • Similar neck tie here
  • Similar sandals here

This modest costume is a sailor. It’s such a unique and cool costume idea!

She is wearing a midi navy and white striped dress, a red neck tie, a white sailor hat, and white sandals.

52. Kate Middleton

Kate Middleton costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar dress here
  • Another similar dress here
  • Similar hat here
  • Similar heels here

Princess Kate Middleton is a very classy and conservative Halloween costume for women to wear.

This costume is a royal blue short sleeve dress, a small blue hat, and pointy black pumps.

53. Rapunzel

Rapunzel costume

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Similar Rapunzel costume here
  • Similar Rapunzel wig here

Rapunzel is the princess in the Disney movie Tangled. She wears a long purple and pink dress.

She has super long hair that she sometimes puts in a braid with flowers. It’s fun to wear a Rapunzel wig with this costume to complete it.

54. Tiana

Tiana costume

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Similar Tiana costume here

This Tiana costume is so cute and would look good on anyone. Princess Tiana is from the movie The Princess and the Frog.

This outfit is what she wears before she’s a princess, when she’s working in a restaurant. It’s a yellow dress and a white apron.

55. Taco

two girls dressed up as tacos with a dog dressed up as a bag of chips

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar taco costume here
  • Brown dress here
  • Similar ankle boots here
  • Multi-colored felt here
  • Tan felt here
  • Avocado balloon here
  • Lime balloon here

If you’re like me, then you love eating tacos! So why not dress up as one? Pretty In The Pines dressed up as a taco in a DIY costume that she made.

She’s wearing a brown dress with different pieces of felt to look like cheese, lettuce, sour cream, and tomatoes, a taco shell vest made from tan felt, and brown ankle boots.

To complete the look, her and her friend are also holding a lime balloon and an avocado balloon. This is a really fun idea for modest food costumes!

56. Sushi

girl dressed up as sushi for halloween

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar sushi costume here
  • Similar headband here
  • Similar white dress here
  • Similar orange pillow here
  • White felt here
  • Black ribbon here
  • Chopsticks here

I think this sushi costume is one of the best modest food costumes! It’s so fun and trendy.

Simply Teee is wearing a white dress for the rice, an orange pillow with white felt that’s attached to her back using thick black satin ribbon, and a headband.

To complete the look, she’s carrying some chopsticks.

57. Starbucks Drink

modest starbucks drink costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar Frappuccino costume here
  • Similar shirt here
  • Similar leggings here
  • Similar boots here
  • White material here
  • Burlap here
  • Green paint here
  • White felt here
  • Cream felt here
  • Headband here

If you love to get a fun drink at Starbucks, then this is the costume for you!

Sparkle Shiny Love made this costume herself. She’s wearing a white long sleeve shirt, black leggings, tan boots, and a DIY Starbucks Frappuccino cup with whipped cream and a headband with a green straw on top.

The Frappuccino is made from stiff white material, burlap, felt, and green paint.

58. Frosted Animal Cookie

Frosted Animal Cookie halloween costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar dress here
  • Similar animal ears headband here
  • Similar heels here
  • Pom poms here
  • Hot glue gun here

Frosted animal cookies are such a nostalgic treat from my childhood, so this is one of my favorite modest food costumes!

Studio DIY made this handmade costume. She’s wearing a pink short sleeve dress with rainbow pom poms glued to it, a pink animal ears headband with pom poms on it, and pink heels.

She’s also holding a cardboard cutout of an animal with pom poms on it.

59. Chipotle

woman dressed up as a chipotle burrito

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar costume here
  • Similar headband here
  • Similar shirt here
  • Similar leggings here
  • Green tissue paper here
  • Red tissue paper here
  • White crinkle cut paper here

Pretty In The Pines dressed up as this fun Chipotle costume.

She has on a headband with green tissue paper for the lettuce. She also is wearing a grey long sleeve shirt and black pants.

She created a Chipotle burrito that has cardboard on the outside with a Chipotle logo on it. It has tissue paper to look like lettuce and tomatoes, and crinkle cut paper shred filler to look like cheese.

60. La Croix

girl dressed up as a la croix can

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar costume here
  • Similar shirt here

This La Croix costume was made by A Kailo Chic Life.

She’s wearing an orange shirt, a La Croix suit over it, and black sandals.

61. Burger

modest burger costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar hamburger costume here
  • Similar dress here
  • Similar shoes here
  • Felt here
  • Hot glue gun here

Studio DIY made this unique hamburger costume.

She’s wearing a tan dress for the hamburger bun and tan shoes. She used a hot glue gun to put different colors of felt on the dress to look like sesame seeds, tomato, lettuce, cheese, and the patty.

62. Cheese

cheese costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar cheese costume here
  • Similar dress here
  • Similar shoes here

Holly Wade from Club Crafted dressed up as cheese for her food costume.

She’s wearing a yellow dress, yellow slip-on shoes, a headband with a slice of cheese on it, and a cheese suit that she’s wearing over the dress.

63. Pizza

pizza costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar pizza costume here
  • Similar shirt here
  • Similar leggings here
  • Shoes here

Kamri from Cute Girl’s Hairstyles is wearing a fun pizza costume, a black t-shirt, black leggings, and black tennis shoes.

This is the perfect costume if your favorite food is pizza!

64. Deer

modest deer costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar deer costume here
  • Similar antlers headband here
  • Similar sweater here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Similar heels here
  • Makeup kit here

This modest deer costume from The Sugared Lemon is just so cute!

She’s wearing deer ears and antlers, a tan cable-knit turtleneck sweater, a cream tulle skirt, and tan heels. She also did really cute deer makeup. This is my favorite of these modest animal costumes.

65. Fox

modest fox costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar fox ears here
  • Similar sweater here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Makeup kit here

Rach Martino dressed up as a fox. This is a really fun modest animal costume!

She’s wearing a fox ears headband, a rust orange cable knit sweater, and an orange skirt. She also did fox makeup on her face. I love the little nose she put on with the makeup!

66. Unicorn

modest unicorn costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar unicorn costume here
  • Unicorn headband here
  • Purple wig here
  • Similar v-neck here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Similar shoes here

Unicorns are so fun and trendy. This unicorn costume is made up of a unicorn horn, purple hair, a mint v-neck shirt, a blush pink tulle skirt, and purple flat shoes.

I love all the pastel colors of this costume.

67. Cat

modest cat costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar cat ears here
  • Similar shirt here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Similar black leggings here
  • Black makeup here
  • Cat tail, collar, and ears here

This modest cat costume is fun for women of all ages and even teens.

This costume is a black cat ears headband, a black long sleeve shirt, a black tulle skirt, black leggings, and black cat makeup. You could also add a tail and a collar to the costume.

68. Spider

modest spider costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar spider headband here
  • Similar spider web face tattoos here
  • Similar shirt here
  • Similar leggings here
  • Similar ankle boots here

I love this take on a spider costume from Pretty Life Girls. Spiders are perfect for Halloween!

She’s wearing a spider headband, spiderweb face tattoos, a black shirt with a white spiderweb on it, black leggings, and black ankle boots.

69. Batwoman

modest batwoman costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar batgirl costume here

Costume Yeti made this DIY Batgirl costume.

She is wearing a black jumpsuit with a yellow Batman logo on it, a yellow cape, yellow boots, a yellow belt, yellow gloves, and a black face mask.

Batman is such a classic superhero, so this is one of my favorite modest superhero costumes!

70. Superwoman

superwoman costume

image credit: sunnyfitlife

Shop this look:

  • Supergirl costume here
  • Superman shirt here
  • White button down shirt here
  • Black suspenders here
  • Shoes here
  • Glasses here
  • Similar pants here

Sunny Fit Life dressed up as the Clark Kent version of Superwoman.

She’s wearing a Superman shirt, a white button down shirt, black suspenders, black pants, glasses, and red tennis shoes.

You really can’t go wrong with dressing up as Superwoman!

71. Elastigirl

elastigirl costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar Elastigirl costume here
  • Another similar Elastigirl costume here
  • Similar boots here

Elastigirl aka Mrs. Incredible is from the Disney movie The Incredibles.

She’s wearing a black and red outfit with The Incredibles logo on it, a black eye mask, and black boots. Viva Veltoro made this DIY Incredibles costume.

72. Wonder Woman

wonder woman costume

image credit

Shop this look:

  • Similar Wonder Woman costume here
  • Wonder Woman shirt here
  • Wonder Woman cape here
  • Crown and cuffs here
  • Wonder Woman skirt here
  • Blue leggings here
  • Similar shoes here

Creative Ramblings dressed up in this Wonder Woman costume.

She’s wearing a red Wonder Woman tee, a gold Wonder Woman headband, gold wrist cuffs, a blue Wonder Woman skirt, a red cape, blue leggings, and heels.

73. Pregnant Skeleton Halloween Costume

Skeleton pregnancy costume

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Similar skeleton shirt here
  • Similar skeleton pants here
  • Similar dog skeleton costume here
  • Similar flower crown here

Skeletons with a little baby skeleton in the belly are the best! I have always wanted to do this, but I’ve never been pregnant in October.

This costume is a shirt and pants that are black with skeleton bones printed on them. It’s my favorite of the maternity Halloween costumes!

The top has a baby skeleton in the belly. She also has on white sandals and a red flower crown. Also, her little dog in the background is wearing a matching skeleton costume.

This is cute no matter what stage of pregnancy you’re in.

74. Dorothy

Dorothy

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Similar dress here
  • Another similar dress here
  • Similar shoes here
  • Similar basket here

This Dorothy from The Wizard of Oz costume is really cute and recognizable.

She is wearing a blue and white gingham dress, red heels, and she has a picnic basket.

75. Mouse Costume

Mouse Costume

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Similar mouse ears here
  • Similar dress here
  • Similar shoes here
  • Face makeup here

This mouse costume is really cute and fun.

She is wearing a light gray dress, a mouse ears headband, and white sneakers. She also used face paint to draw on a mouse nose and whiskers.

76. Bandit Costume For Women

Bandit Costume For Women

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Similar bag here
  • Similar dress here
  • Similar mask here
  • Similar beanie here
  • Similar boots here

This bandit costume is so cool and edgy for Halloween.

She is wearing a black and white striped dress, a black eye mask, a black beanie, and black combat boots. She’s also holding a money bag.

77. Fox Costume For Women

Fox Costume For Women

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Similar fox ears here
  • Similar dress here
  • Similar vest here

This fox costume is really modest, cute, and easy to put together.

She is wearing an orange dress, a fox ears headband, and a white furry vest.

78. Cruella DeVil Costume

Cruella DeVil Costume

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Similar Cruella costume here
  • Cruella wig here

This Cruella Devil costume is simple and so chic.

She is wearing a white fur coat with a black dress, and red gloves. You definitely need your hair to be half black and half white if you’re going to be Cruella.

79. Modest Ariel Costume

Modest Ariel Costume

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Similar sweater here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Similar heels here
  • Similar headband here
  • Similar necklace here
  • Similar plush here
  • Ariel wig here

This modest Ariel costume is really chic and so fun. It’s perfect for teachers or wearing to the office.

She has on a purple sweater, a green pleated midi skirt, a red headband, a shell necklace, and red heels. She’s also holding a red crab plush to represent Sebastian.

You could add a red Ariel wig if you want to.

80. Modest Minnie Mouse Costume

Modest Minnie Mouse Costume

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Similar ears here
  • Similar sweater here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Similar heels here

This Minnie Mouse costume is so cute and easy to put together.

She is wearing red Minnie ears, a black sweater, a red polka dot midi skirt, and black heels.

81. Modest Snow White Costume

Modest Snow White Costume

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Top here
  • Similar skirt here
  • Similar heels here
  • Similar headband here
  • Ribbon here

This simple Snow White Halloween costume is so cute.

She is wearing a blue top, a yellow pleated skirt, red heels, and a red bow headband. She put a red ribbon around her waist too.

82. Farmer Costume

Farmer Costume

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Similar hat here
  • Similar shirt here
  • Similar jeans here
  • Similar booties here

This farmer costume is simple and easy to put together.

She is wearing a tan hat, a plaid shirt, distressed jeans, and brown booties.

83. Tinker Bell

Tinker Bell

image credit

Shop this costume:

  • Similar skirt here
  • Similar top here
  • Similar wand here

This simple Tinker Bell outfit is a green shirt, a green tulle skirt, heels, and a fairy wand.

Pin this image to save these Halloween costumes for women for later!

modest halloween costumes

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Filed Under: Holiday

Subscribe

to get blog updates.

Previous Post: « 31 Funny Fashion Puns That Will Surely Make You Laugh
Next Post: 6 Things You’ll Wish You Brought On Your Mission »

Primary Sidebar

Welcome

Elizabeth Morgan who owns Cleo Madison

I'm Liz, a modest fashion blogger and twin momma. It's my mission to help you find modest clothing for every occasion! Read More

Join The Newsletter

Get notified of new posts and receive a FREE eBook with all of my best modest fashion hacks!

Follow Along

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • TikTok
  • YouTube

Footer

COPYRIGHT © 2025 CLEO MADISON

About • Contact • Privacy Policy • Accessibility • Terms & Conditions